充耳不闻与从谏如流:建议采择研究述评
Rejecting or Accepting Suggestions:A Review of Researches on Advice Taking
作者：周浩;
Author：
收稿日期： 年卷（期）页码：2012,(04):-105-111
期刊名称：四川大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
Journal Name：Journal of Sichuan University (Social Science Edition）
关键字：建议采择;决策;建议
Key words：
基金项目：国家自然科学基金资助项目“家长式领导对下属进谏行为的影响”(71002047);;
四川大学中央高校基本科研业务费研究专项项目(skqy201113)
中文摘要
建议采择指的是决策者对于他人建议的采纳或者拒绝。通过对建议采择领域研究成果的梳理,介绍了建议采择的概念和作用,分析了建议采择的经典研究范式(JAS),着重探讨了影响建议采择的决策者、建议者以及决策情境因素。最后,对建议采择领域未来的研究方向进行了展望,包括提高JAS的生态效度,分析决策者的建议质量识别机制,基于面子、关系等中国文化背景因素分析中国人的建议采择机制。
参考文献
②Albert E.Mannes,“Are We Wise about the Wisdom of Crowds?The Use of Group Judgments in Belief Revision,”Management Science,Vol.55,No.8,2009,pp.1267-1279.
③Bradley Dawson,“Advice Worth Taking,”EC&M Electrical Construction&Maintenance,Vol.107,No.8,2008,pp.20-22.
①Dan Ciampa,Taking Advice:How Leaders Get Good Counsel and Use it Wisely,Boston:Harvard Business School Press,2006,pp.1-3.
②Ilan Yaniv and Maxim Milyavsky,“Using Advice from Multiple Sources to Revise and Improve Judgment,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.103,No.1,2007,pp.104-120.
③Leigh P.Tost,Francesca Gino and Richard P.Larrick,“Power,Competitiveness,and Advice Taking:Why the Powerful Don’t Listen,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.117,No.1,2012,pp.53-65.
④Francesca Gino,“Do We Listen to Advice Just Because We Paid for It?The Impact of Advice Cost on Its Use,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.107,No.2,2008,pp.234-245.
⑤Janet A.Sniezek and Lyn M.Van Swol,“Trust,Confidence,and Expertise in a Judge-advisor System,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.84,No.2,2001,pp.288-307.
⑥Nigel Harvey and Ilan Fischer,“Taking Advice:Accepting Help,Improving Judgment,and Sharing Responsibility,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.70,No.2,1997,pp.117-133.
⑦Ilan Yaniv,“Receiving Other People’s Advice:Influence and Benefit,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.93,No.1,2004,pp.1-13.
①Ilan Yaniv and Eli Kleinberger,“Advice Taking in Decision Making:Egocentric Discounting and Reputation Formation,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.83,No.2,2000,pp.260-281.
④Nigel Harvey,Clare Harries and Ilan Fischer,“Using Advice and Assessing its Quality,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.81,No.2,2000,pp.252-273.
⑤Adam D.Galinsky,Joe C.Magee,Ena Inesi and Deborah H.Gruenfeld,“Power and Perspectives not Taken,”Psy-chological Science,Vol.17,No.12,2006,pp.1068-1074;Adam D.Galinsky,Joe C.Magee,Deborah H.Gruenfeld,Jenni-fer A.Whitson and Katie A.Liljenquist,“Power Reduces the Press of the Situation:Implications for Creativity,Conformity,and Dissonance,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,Vol.95,No.6,2008,pp.1450-1466.
⑥Kelly E.See,Elizabeth W.Morrison,Naomi B.Rothman and Jack B.Soll,“The Detrimental Effects of Power on Confidence,Advice Taking,and Accuracy,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.116,No.2,2011,pp.272-285.
⑦Tost,Gino and Larrick,“Power,Competitiveness,and Advice Taking,”pp.53-65.
⑧Joe C.Magee,Adam D.Galinsky and Deborah H.Gruenfeld,“Power,Propensity to Negotiate,and Moving First in Competitive Interactions,”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,Vol.33,No.2,2007,pp.200-212.
⑨Reeshad S.Dalal and Silvia Bonaccio,“What Types of Advice Do Decision Makers Prefer,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.112,No.1,2010,pp.11-23.
①Francesca Gino and Maurice E.Schweitzer,“Blinded by Anger or Feeling the Love:How Emotions Influence Advice Taking,”Journal of Applied Psychology,Vol.93,No.5,2008,pp.1165-1173.
②Yaniv and Kleinberger,“Advice Taking in Decision Making,”pp.260-281.
③Joa S.Lim and Marcus O'Connor,“Judgmental Adjustment of Initial Forecasts:Its Effectiveness and Biases,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,Vol.8,No.4,1995,pp.149-168.
④Lyn M.Van Swol and Janet A.Sniezek,“Factors Affecting the Acceptance of Expert Advice,”British Journal of Social Psychology,Vol.44,No.3,2005,pp.443-461.
⑤Nigel Harvey and Clare Harries,“Effects of Judges’Forecasting on Their Later Combination of Forecasts for the Same Outcomes,”International Journal of Forecasting,Vol.20,No.3,2004,pp.391-409.
⑥Yaniv and Milyavsky,“Using Advice from Multiple Sources to Revise and Improve Judgment,”pp.104-120.
⑦Yaniv,“Receiving Other People’s Advice,”pp.1-13.
⑧Janna T.Deelstra,Maria C.W.Peeters,Wilmar B.Schaufeli,Wolfgang Stroebe,Fred R.H.Zijlstra and Lorenz P.van Doornen,“Receiving Instrumental Support at Work:When Help is Not Welcome,”Journal of Applied Psychology,Vol.88,No.2,2003,pp.324-331.
⑨Ilan Yaniv and Shoham Choshen-Hillel,“Exploiting the Wisdom of Others to Make Better Decisions:Suspending Judgment Reduces Egocentrism and Increases Accuracy,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,in press.
①Jack B.Soll and Richard P.Larrick,“Strategies for Revising Judgment:How(and How Well)People Use Others’Opinions,”Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory,and Cognition,Vol.35,No.3,2009,pp.780-805.
②Bo Feng and Erina L.MacGeorge,“Predicting Receptiveness to Advice:Characteristics of the Problem,the Advicegiver,and the Recipient,”Southern Journal of Communication,Vol.71,No.1,2006,pp.67-85.
③Francesca Gino,Jen Shang and Rachel Croson,“The Impact of Information from Similar or Different Advisors on Judgment,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.108,No.2,2009,pp.287-302.
④Ilan Yaniv,Shoham Choshen-Hillel and Maxim Milyavsky,“Receiving Advice on Matters of Taste:Similarity,Majority Influence,and Taste Discrimination,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.115,No.1,2011,pp.111-120.
⑤Andreas Oehler and Daniel Kohlert,“Financial Advice Giving and Taking—Where Are the Market’s Self-healing Powers and a Functioning Legal Framework When We Need Them,”Journal of Consumer Policy,Vol.32,No.2,2009,pp.91-116.
⑥Thomas Webb,“Advice-taking as an Unobtrusive Measure of Prejudice,”Behavior Research Methods,Vol.43,No.4,2011,pp.953-963.
⑦Francesca Gino and Don A.Moore,“Effects of Task Difficulty on Use of Advice,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,Vol.20,No.1,2007,pp.21-35.
⑧Tiffany B.White,“Consumer Trust and Advice Acceptance:The Moderating Roles of Benevolence,Expertise,and Negative Emotions,”Journal of Consumer Psychology,Vol.15,No.2,2005,pp.141-148.
⑨Gino,“Do We Listen to Advice Just Because We Paid for It?”pp.234-245.
①Anthony G.Patt,Hannah R.Bowles and David W.Cash,“Mechanisms for Enhancing the Credibility of an Adviser:Prepayment and Aligned Incentives,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,Vol.19,No.4,2006,pp.347-359.
②Gino,“Do We Listen to Advice Just Because We Paid for It?”pp.234-245.
③Eva Jonas and Dieter Frey,“Information Search and Presentation in Advisor-client Interactions,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol.91,No.2,2003,pp.154-168.
④Liat Hadar and Ilan Fischer,“Giving Advice under Uncertainty:What You Do,What You Should Do,and What Others Think You Do,”Journal of Economic Psychology,Vol.29,No.5,2008,pp.667-683.
⑤Oehler and Kohlert,“Financial Advice Giving and Taking,”pp.91-116.
①郑伯壎、周丽芳、樊景立:《家长式领导量表:三元模式的建构与测量》,《本土心理学研究》(台北)2000年第14期。
②黄光国:《人情与面子:中国人的权力游戏》,见杨国枢编:《中国人的心理》,南京:江苏教育出版社,2006年,第226-248页。
③Liang H.Lin and Yu L.Ho,“Guanxi and OCB:The Chinese Cases,”Journal of Business Ethics,Vol.96,No.2,2010,pp.285-298.
【关闭】
